Start with the work, not the sales claim
Write down what is being replaced: employee support, device maintenance, security operations, vendor coordination, backup administration, or another defined responsibility. Compare the same work, coverage, and period. A cheaper proposal that leaves important tasks with your employees is not an equivalent service.
Include onboarding, retained software, excluded projects, and the effort needed to manage the relationship. Leave a cost out of both sides only when it genuinely stays the same. A current expense counts as a saving only when the new arrangement actually eliminates it.
Separate three kinds of value
| Value | What counts | What does not |
|---|---|---|
| Cash savings | Invoices, overtime, or other expenses that will genuinely stop. | A salary that stays on the payroll. |
| Usable capacity | Recovered working time that employees can put to productive use. | Every minute saved automatically becoming sales or profit. |
| Risk and resilience | Better recovery evidence, clearer ownership, or reduced exposure. | An assumed avoided breach multiplied by a dramatic headline cost. |
Risk reduction matters even when it cannot be credibly converted into a dollar return. NIST's small-business guide treats cybersecurity as work to understand, manage, and review—not a guaranteed financial return from a particular subscription. [1]
Use a baseline you can explain
Estimate recurring interruption hours using a representative period, not your worst outage. Separate employees' lost working time from the technician's labor. Identify how much time involves preventable recurring issues versus legitimate requests, training, or changes the business needs anyway.
Agree how the estimate will be checked after service begins. A proposed 90-day review is a planning choice, not a promise that all improvements will be measurable by then. Keep the comparison fair when headcount, applications, or workload changes.
A hypothetical example with an honest result
Assume current replaceable support costs $2,500 monthly, plus $6,000 in other annual expenses that the proposal would eliminate. The new service costs $3,000 monthly, with $200 monthly in excluded recurring costs and $2,400 in setup. These are invented planning inputs, not prices from Blue Tree Technology®.
| First-year comparison | Amount |
|---|---|
| Current replaceable cash cost | $36,000 |
| Proposed recurring cost plus setup | $40,800 |
| Cash result | $4,800 more spending |
| Illustrative usable-capacity value | $9,000 |
| Net modeled economic benefit | $4,200 |
The capacity assumption is 20 employees saving 1.5 hours each per month, valued at $50 per hour, with only 50% of that time converted into productive capacity: 20 × 1.5 × 12 × $50 × 50% = $9,000.
That is not $9,000 arriving in the bank. The business spends more cash. Counting the stated capacity value produces a modeled first-year return of $4,200 ÷ $40,800 = 10.3%. This uses the full proposed first-year cost as the denominator; it is not a claim of 10.3% profit growth or a guaranteed result.
Challenge the assumptions before accepting the answer
At 25% productive recapture, capacity is worth $4,500 and the modeled result becomes a $300 loss. At 0%, the result is the $4,800 cash increase. There is no cash payback in this example because even the recurring cash cost rises.
Do not also add lost revenue for the same blocked work, or count a removed payroll cost and that person's recovered time twice. Review cash affordability separately from capacity and risk.
The better buying question: can the provider explain a credible improvement, complete costs, and how both parties will verify it? Ask Blue Tree Technology® to work through those assumptions with you.
Verification source
[1] NIST: Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 Small Business Quick-Start Guide. Calculator formulas and example are our illustrative model, not research findings.
